I too am a member of DVC, Old Key West! I have stayed at Old Key West, Boardwalk and Vero Beach. I have seen the inside of the rooms at Wilderness Lodge, they are nice, similar in quality and size to OKW. When I have my family, I stay at Old Key West, the rooms are bigger, it is quiet, and the pools are easier to get to. If it is just me and my wife, we always stay at Boardwalk. You can’t beat the restaurants and the night life. I love being able to walk into Epcot in the World Showcase when it isn’t open yet. So nice to be able to look at the lands as you walk by not having to weave in and out of people. The rooms are smaller, but when there are just two of us, who cares? I think the new beach club villas will be great, more quiet than Boardwalk but a great location.
We stayed at Vero Beach in 1999. We were upgraded from a two bedroom to one of the beach houses. If you have never done that, it is not to be missed. Great views and wonderful sounds to fall asleep by.