WOW! This is a really hard decision. Fulton’s is definitely one of my favorites while we’ve eaten at Artist Point twice in the last year and several times in total and liked it every time.
Seeing as it’s out of pocket, and there is a much bigger range of entrees at Fulton’s, I’d lean that way, especially if you’re looking for seafood.
Artist Point suffers from what in general all of WDW’s restaurants suffer from since the roll out of the DDP in 2005, only about 4 appetizers and 8 entrees on the menu.