I was actually in the same boat as you this time last year and we decided to purchase as WL. We love the great outdoors feel and the beauty of the whole resort. I ultimately loved the location. My DH loves taking the boat to MK (I think being a boat driver is WDW is a secret fantasy of his) and you are just a short distance away from all the activities at Fort Wilderness, Contemporary, Poly, and GF.
AKL is also a beautiful resort, but when we stayed there I felt very seperated from everything. Other than AK, you are really seperated from every place else I feel.
Ultimately, you need to decide what is most important to you and make your decision based on that.