We have rented from DVCRentalStore.com twice. We rent our points from them, get them to add our dining, and then we add our park tickets from undercovertourist.com. It usually saves us a ridiculous amount of money. It sounds like a pain, but when we get to the resort, we take our paper tickets and the keys to the kingdom card to the concierge and they put them all on the same card. Never had a problem with it.
To give you an idea, we got a $3800 Bay Lake Tower room last summer for less than $1500, and this fall we are doing a $2400 Wilderness Lodge room for $900. Renting points is the best way to go.
I think the only trick was that you have to say you are the “guest of so and so”, if they ever ask. Otherwise, it is a normal vacation. Oh yeah, the DVC rooms don’t come with maid service every day. Last year we paid for it 3 days when we were there. I think it was $30 a day. But, still MUCH cheaper than the normal room.
Check out DVCRentalStore, they did us and our friends great.
I understand David’s DVC Rental is great too, just had a lot of luck with DVC Rental Store.