[QUOTE=bethishooked;1005907]For our trip in March, we decided to do ADR’s for fear of crowds. So I think I’m all set, when I read in another thread how magical it was to sit outside at Tony’s watching Spectromagic. So out of curiousity, I see if there is availability, and there was. Now I have two ADRs for that day, Liberty Tree and Tonys. My problem is when I read reviews, Liberty Tree gets rave reviews about the food, and Tonys does not. So, do I want to go with good food, or go with atmosphere? Your opinions are very much welcome![/QUOTE]
Tony’s food is really hit and miss. Some people have had good results, others (like me)… not so much. Being able to time dinner around the parade can be tricky, but I’ve heard that it’s truly magical.
With that, the food at LTT is consistent, the service is typically very good, and the atmosphere is downright homey. It’s unlike an experience anywhere else in WDW. It’s unfortunate that it’s no longer a Character Meal experience, but worth it nonetheless. Ironically, it’s rarely crowded now, so you’re more likely to get special attention.
I’d take LTT over Tony’s