LMM's Magic Band/FP+/MyDisneyExperience REVIEW!


#1

Hello, everyone! Just back from a fabulous weekend getaway to Walt Disney World! I wanted to do a Magic Band review separately from my regular TR just because it’s such a hot topic in the Disneysphere.

We stayed at the Beach Club Resort which was one of the resorts selected for October testing. We booked through Travelocity, and knowing that BC had been selected for Magic Band testing, I immediately went online to Disneyworld.com and added our reservation to my MyDisneyExperience profile. If you’ve booked at a Disney resort which is testing (or may soon be testing) Magic Bands through an online booking agent, I wrote a tutorial on how to link that reservation to your MyDisneyExperience account.

After linking that reservation, because the resort had already been selected for October Magic Band testing, I was immediately given the option of ordering and customizing our Magic Bands. By “customizing” Magic Bands, I mean changing the color and the name written on each band. If you do not customize your band, then it will be grey. You also have a very short period of time between being told that you’ve been invited for testing (if you booked further in advance than we did, you’ll receive an invitation to test Magic Bands) to customize your bands. I also wrote a tutorial on how to customize your Magic Bands through MyDisneyExperience.

The bands seem to be overnighted, as we received ours the day after they shipped. It’s very important that if you booked through an online booking agent such as Travelocity, Expedia, Hotels, etc. that you [U]change your shipping address from their office address to your own home address[/U]. If not, your bands will be sent out into Neverland. If you do not order your bands before the customization and shipping date, they will be grey, and you will get them when you check into the hotel.

Okay, now time for the fun part…

We decided this year that we would use annual passes. We had already purchased two annual passes in the past few years to get room discounts which we just hadn’t activated yet. I was able to add one of those will call APs (the one purchased in 2012) to MyDisneyExperience, but I was unable to add the will call AP purchased in June 2011 to MyDisneyExperience. And then we ended up waiting to purchase the other two APs when we got to WDW.

You cannot purchase annual passes at the resorts. It must be done at a theme park. So the morning we arrived, we went to guest relations at Hollywood Studios to purchase and activate our APs. We had all APs added to our Magic Bands, but were also given a physical card. You must show your annual pass card in order to get a discount - for some reason, even though the system knows that the ticket on your band is an AP, it will not automatically apply the discount. I’m sure this could be something that is programmed to automatically add in the future which would speed up transactions.

For curiosity’s sake, we did try getting FPs with our AP cards after entering the park with our Magic Bands. It worked! My guess is that the card is linked to both, and you could enter the park with either the Magic Band or the card, and it knows that you’re in the park, so the annual pass is activated - not just the band or just the card. I’m sure they could change this, and they might change it in the future.

Review time -

[B]MAGIC BANDS[/B]

[B]What we [U]LOVED[/U] about Magic Bands:[/B]

The convenience and speed of transaction. It’s so nice not having to dig your wallet out of your bag to purchase something or to have to dig for your room key at the end of the day. Really, the convenience has spoiled us! I can’t wait for them to add this to cruise ships and for competitors to start trying this out. Disney is leading the future here, I’m convinced!

That the Magic Bands could be worn in the pool. My sister and I usually go to the pool together with no pool bag - just cover-ups, towels, and a room key. We’ll hide our room key inside our cover-ups while we go swim. Not anymore!!! The fact that we can wear our Magic Bands in the pool and hot tub is awesome!!!

[B]What needs improvement:[/B]

This was mainly a Food & Wine Festival issue, and it wouldn’t be a problem if I wasn’t spoiled by the convenience of Magic Bands. Whenever I purchased an adult beverage from F&W, they asked to see my ID (understandable). I then had to dig through my bag to find my wallet and hand them my ID - completely ruining the convenience of the Magic Band and slowing down the line. I know I’m not the only young adult visiting F&W. There are several solutions to this, and I don’t know if it should be approached as a F&W solution or a Magic Band solution. For example, F&W could issue wristbands confirming that young-looking guests are indeed the legal drinking age. As for Magic Bands… they have my freaking FINGERPRINT - I think there’s something that could be done to confirm that I’m legal.

People are still a little confused getting inside the park… and it might be the lack of turnstiles that confuses them (really - it’s so weird to see no turnstiles!). But it’s not clear when you should put your finger on the scanner. I approached it as once the Mickey head lights up white, put your finger on the scanner, and then it will spin a white circle around your finger and then turn Mickey green. However, my parents and others seemed to be waiting longer to start scanning their finger. I think people could be getting in a lot faster if they just start scanning their finger sooner, but there aren’t really clear instructions on how to do it.

[B]FastPass+[/B]

[B]What we [U]LOVED[/U] about FastPass+:[/B]

It’s awesome to not have to worry about being in the park early before the FastPasses run out. I had good luck with making us FP+ reservations the night before (not so much the day of).

One day, we went to AK in the morning, and I made our FP+ reservations for Epcot that afternoon - something we would have never been able to do with regular FP. We were able to benefit from the light crowds of getting to the park early while still getting FPs for another park.

What needs improvement:

It’s annoying that Disney gives you different “options” and that you have to “change” them to get exactly what you want. Why can’t you just see all of the available times up front? Disney is trying to get people to do certain things by not showing them everything available. I guess that this might work in my favor for now, since I realize that all you have to do is click “change time” to see all of the available times for the attraction that day.

I’d really like the option to double or triple-up on FPs for one attraction… or just choose one or two FPs. For example, for Epcot, I only really wanted to FP Soarin’ and Test Track. I would’ve loved to FP Soarin’ twice. But I had to choose three different FPs, so I got another FP that I ended up not using… this is a WASTE because someone else might have wanted that FP, but I kept them from getting it.

It would be nice to be able to get FPs in different parks. Maybe this is something they’ll add later.

I found a GLITCH in the system:

Well, I think for it to be a true glitch, it has to work every time, and I don’t know if it does or not because I only did it once. Anyway, I somehow got FOUR FP+s for Magic Kingdom… TWO for Space Mountain (attached as an image below). How did this happen? I was trying to change the times for FP+s because I made them for the afternoon, but Rachel wanted them earlier. Well, at one point, there was a “system error” when I was trying to change the time for Space Mountain. I shut the app down and opened it back up… and learned that I now had two Space Mountain FP times - one for the time I had, and one for the time I was changing it to. The four FPs showed up on my MyDisneyExperience account, as well as my dad’s.

My Disney Experience App

I don’t think it’s the most user-friendly. I had a difficult time understanding where to see my FP+ reservations after I made them (under “My Reservations” or “Plans”), and I think there are a lot of redundancies. However, that being said, I installed this app on my mother and my father’s phones. My dad was having a difficult time using the app… griping, griping, griping. And then I look over at my MOM (who has all of 5 apps on her phone) who is quietly looking at our FP+ reservations… something that I hadn’t even figured out how to do yet. My non-techy sister was also really good with the app. Though she didn’t have it on her phone, she would take my phone or my mother’s phone and look over the app. This makes me wonder if it actually is very user-friendly… to the non-technology person and just overly simple to everyone else. It’s probably blatantly obvious and I was just overlooking everything.

Overall My Disney Experience

[B]My initial concerns which were shut down after testing:[/B]

That the Magic Band would be uncomfortable… not at all! The Magic Bands are super lightweight and don’t feel sticky on your skin. I also kept mine a little loose so that it could slide around on my wrist and wouldn’t be uncomfortably stuck.

That we wouldn’t be able to get FP+ reservations unless we planned months in advance… not true. While I didn’t have that much good luck with day-of FP+ options (disclaimer: this was at 10AM when regular FPs were also being quickly dispensed… TSM was already well into the evening, and I was able to make a FP+ reservation for TSM for that evening. It was quite on-par with regular FP that day), I had good luck getting FP+ that I wanted when booking the night before. The only point when this wasn’t the case was the night before Epcot when the park had morning EMH - FP+ was distributed well into the afternoon, the first one available at 4:30PM.

That FastPass+ will make us all theme park commandos… nah. You’re only making three FP+ reservations per day. Will you know what park you’re going to be in that day? Probably. Do you know what you would FP for that park that day? Probably.

[B]Final thoughts:[/B]

I loved having Magic Bands and FP+. I’ll admit - I was one of the original skeptics when the “rumor” first hit the Disneysphere. But after my initial skepticism and a lot of the rumors proving to be false (that you would have to PAY for Magic Bands/FP+, that you got more FP+ options based on your resort tier, that the bands actually tap into your brain and play a continuous “it’s a small world” inside your head… okay, I made that one up), I became intrigued by the Magic Bands and all of the benefits they could bring to a Disney vacation. Will I be nostalgic for the old FP system? Heck yeah! My poor dad didn’t know what to do with himself, not having to run for FPs (he eased his anxiety by becoming huffy with people who were slow to scan their bands in the FP+ line… fellow Disney park-goers, my family is very sorry!). But we’re in the middle of PROGRESS here and this is awesome!

So I’m going to leave you with a quote by the man behind the mouse who started it all (and a man whose thoughts and ideals the Disneysphere continues to debate about 40+ years after his death):

We keep moving forward , opening new doors, and doing new things, because we’re curious and curiosity keeps leading us down new paths.

  • Walt Disney

#2

Excellent review, Victoria. I have been looking forward to reading your thoughts and hearing of your experience with the Magic Bands. Thank you so much for sharing.


#3

As someone who has to deal sometimes from the selling adult beverage side, there is a lot at stake in selling to underage minors. Sure the Magic Bands have your information but…did Disney actually check your ID? And what if you had your MBand to your under age roommate?


#4

Thanks for the first hand experience Victoria!

I am one that has not been excited about the FP+ system because we don’t plan anything ahead of time. Now having read about it’s actual use here on Mousebuzz—I think we will “survive” by planning the day before.


#5

Excellent review Victoria!


#6

Being in the college age bracket, I may or may not have heard through the grapevine that it’s actually easier to buy underage at F&W now with a good fake than it could be if they started using Magic Bands as a form of identification. Disney will be able to see this themselves when they realize that some minors have been successful at purchasing alcohol… with their own Magic Bands.

My logic is this: I’ve been on many cruises, and all of your identifying information is linked to your Sea Pass/Cruise Card/KTTW/etc. You verify your ID with your passport or driver’s license, and they take your photo when you board the ship. Whenever you purchase anything, your ID is scanned and your photo pops up. They don’t want you to have to carry around extra ID because then you have to think about what you’re buying. That slows down sales.

I think that Disney should start taking identification for guests 18 and older when they check in. They’ll know exactly who is 21 and older. While they could also begin attaching your photo to your Magic Band… they scan your FINGERPRINT. It is much more difficult for someone to use a fake fingerprint than a fake photo ID. Scan your fingerprint when you buy alcohol - instantly, they’ll be able to know if the person is old enough to purchase.


#7

Excellent thoughts and that very may be something they do later. Since they ar still testing, I guess we are still looking at the bare bones system. Tweaks are sure to come especially if it means more revenue for Disney.


#8

Thanks for your review…I hope I get to try them in January!
Ooh, and I just realized that today I am DOUBLE DIGIT DANCING! WOOT!


#9

LOVE the review, Victoria! I can’t wait to try out the new Magic Bands and FP+ in May when we are in the World. The convenience of the bands is what I find so exciting. It was always such a pain to check to make sure each of my kids had their cards when we left in the morning.


#10

Thanks for your overview and tutorial…


#11

Loved it! Thanks :happy:


#12

Thanks, guys!


#13

Loved your review, Victoria and I agreed with almost all of it. I was a bit of a Magic Band/FPP skeptic but overall I really enjoyed using the system. I was also able to change FPs on the fly and got desirable FPs day of even when most paper FPs were already gone. (I changed our Soarin FP 3 times in one day!)

The lack of turnstiles is super weird and we encountered a few CMs who were barely paying attention. I still think it would be sort of easy to just walk on in (not that I would ever do that, obviously). Also, some of the CMs we encountered at the gate (mostly at International Gateway) were not providing a lot of instruction to folks coming in. My mom stood there with her MB up to the Mickey Head for ages before I even realized she did not have her finger in the scanner. The CM standing at her Mickey Head never even looked down or said anything to help.

As far as the inconvenience of the carding at F&W, I think that is something that won’t go away anytime soon. I know Disney is super sensitive about possibly serving to minors. One of the many reasons I love going to F&W is that they still card me at every booth and I am worlds away from being 21. :laugh:


#14

Thank you for the tips. I really didn’t know much about the magic bands until this weekend. It’s amazing how quickly they can set them up. We just really had a chance to see them this Saturday at a community street fair where a local travel agent had some on her display. Went home Saturday night, logged into my Disney Experience (already had an account reservation with all of our Nov. trip information in it). Longest part of customizing was getting everyone in the family to decide on what color they wanted. :angry:

Anyway, completed the order Saturday night, got the email this afternoon that they’ve been shipped, and the USPS tracking number. Went to the USPS website and found out they should be here tomorrow. Pretty quick!

DD and DS are in charge of figuring out how to link the FP+ to the bands. Glad to hear night before worked fine, as we make park decisions each night based a number of factors, especially where the deaf interpreters are going to be each day (DW is deaf).


#15

Ours arrived today!!


#16

I really expected to get a survey from WDW concerning the FP testing. Guess the bottom line is that this is a soft opening and not really a way to test opinion of the system. Fast Pass as we know it is dead.


#17

They arrive so fast and the packaging is pretty nice. I can’t help wondering how much all of that must be costing and thus adding to my ticket or room prices. LOL


#18

Great Review. Hopefully, we’ll get to try it soon ourselves.