Oh my gosh, this is like comparing the sun to the moon. VASTLY different places. One is good, kind of neat, and sort of fun. One is fantastic, great atmosphere, and just amazing. Guess which? Seriously, do Ohana. It is phenomenal, fun, and if you time it right, you have a great view of the lake and fireworks. Ohana all the way! We would do both anytime, but if you have a choice of only just one, Ohana every time.