I’ve only stayed at Old Key West once, during Girl Trip last August and I really liked it. The grounds are extremely lush, and the rooms are BIG! I really loved the bathrooms in the studio. They were bigger than any other DVC studio I’ve stayed in. The store & grocery section is big & I really like the pool. The main pool didn’t seem as big to me as other DVC resorts but it’s fun! We didn’t eat at Olivia’s but the menu on Allears looks good. I also loved that there was a boat that went to DtD, so convenient!
It’s a big resort, especially if you didn’t have a rental car but the bus stops are pretty close to every building it seems & I always noticed buses coming and going.